Muhammad Ismail Khalid

Law Firm Website Analysis: What to Check and How to Fix It

By , Full Stack Developer and AI Automation Engineer. . 7 min read.

Topic: Law Firm Websites

On this page
  1. What a law firm website analysis covers
  2. 1. Speed and Core Web Vitals
  3. 2. Mobile experience
  4. 3. Contact and intake
  5. 4. Practice area pages
  6. 5. Local SEO
  7. 6. Trust and ethics rules
  8. 7. Accessibility
  9. 8. Tracking and maintenance
  10. How to run the analysis in one afternoon
  11. What to fix first
  12. The short answer
  13. Frequently asked questions

A law firm website analysis checks one thing above all: does the site turn visitors into consultations? A good review looks at eight areas: speed, mobile experience, contact and intake, practice area pages, local SEO, trust and ethics rules, accessibility, and tracking.

Most firms find their biggest problems in the boring places. A slow mobile page, a phone number you can't tap, a contact form that emails a partner who left last year. This guide walks through each area, what to check, which free tools to use and what to fix first.

At MIK Web Solutions we build websites and lead follow-up systems for US law firms, so this is the checklist we'd recommend any firm run before spending more on ads or SEO.

What a law firm website analysis covers

Area What to check Free tool
Speed Core Web Vitals on mobile PageSpeed Insights, Search Console
Mobile Tap-to-call, readable text, working forms Your own phone
Contact and intake Forms deliver, calls are answered, fast reply A test submission and a test call
Practice area pages One clear page per practice area and location A site crawl or your sitemap
Local SEO Google Business Profile, consistent details, structured data Rich Results Test
Trust and ethics No misleading claims, lawyer name and contact info Your state bar's rules
Accessibility WCAG 2.2 Level AA basics Keyboard and a screen reader
Tracking Calls and forms counted as conversions Your analytics account
Law firm website analysis checklist showing the eight areas to review, from speed to tracking
The eight areas of a law firm website analysis.

1. Speed and Core Web Vitals

Speed comes first because most legal searches happen on phones, often in a stressful moment. Google measures real-world page experience with three Core Web Vitals, and publishes the thresholds for each.

Metric What it measures Good Poor
Largest Contentful Paint (LCP) How fast the main content loads 2.5 s or less Over 4 s
Interaction to Next Paint (INP) How fast the page reacts to taps 200 ms or less Over 500 ms
Cumulative Layout Shift (CLS) How much the layout jumps 0.1 or less Over 0.25

Google scores these at the 75th percentile of visits, and the same thresholds apply to mobile and desktop. Check the Core Web Vitals report in Search Console for field data across the site, then run your homepage and top practice pages through PageSpeed Insights.

Law firm website analysis speed targets: good and poor thresholds for LCP, INP and CLS
Core Web Vitals targets to check during the speed review.

The usual causes on law firm sites are oversized hero images or videos, heavy page builders, chat widgets that load on every page and too many tracking scripts. Fix the largest image on each key page first, then remove scripts nobody uses.

2. Mobile experience

Open the site on your own phone, not a desktop browser shrunk down. Check that:

  • The phone number is visible without scrolling and starts a call when tapped
  • Text is readable without zooming
  • Menus open and close properly
  • Forms are short and the keyboard doesn't hide the submit button
  • Pop-ups don't cover the page or block the call button

If you have to pinch, zoom or hunt for the phone number, a potential client will too, and the next result on Google is one tap away.

3. Contact and intake

This is where most leads are lost, and no automated tool will catch it. Test it like a potential client would:

  1. Submit every form on the site, including the ones on practice area pages.
  2. Check where it goes. Confirm the notification reaches someone who still works there, and that the lead lands in your CRM or case management system.
  3. Call the main number during business hours and after hours. Note who answers and what happens if nobody does.
  4. Time the reply. Write down how long it takes for anyone to respond to the test form.

A slow reply is often a bigger problem than the website itself. If leads wait hours for a call back, look at automated follow-up such as an instant text reply and a missed call text back. Our GoHighLevel pros and cons review explains how one platform handles that kind of lead follow-up and where it falls short.

4. Practice area pages

Search engines and visitors both need a clear page for each service. Check that:

  • Each main practice area has its own page, not a single "Services" page listing everything
  • Each page explains who you help, what the process looks like and how to get in touch
  • Pages are written for people with a legal problem, not for other lawyers
  • Every page has a clear next step, such as a call button or short form
  • Title tags and headings name the practice area and the city you serve

Thin pages with two paragraphs and no call to action are common. They rarely rank and rarely convert.

5. Local SEO

Most law firm clients search locally, so check the signals Google uses for local results:

  • Google Business Profile. It's claimed, the category is correct, hours are current and the website link points to the right page.
  • Consistent details. The firm name, address and phone number match on the website, the profile and major directories.
  • Structured data. Google's guidance is to use the most specific LocalBusiness type available, and to include name and address, which are required, plus recommended details like telephone, url and opening hours. On schema.org, LegalService is the LocalBusiness subtype for law firms, with Attorney as a more specific type.
  • Reviews markup. Google's LocalBusiness documentation says review and rating markup is only for sites that capture reviews about other local businesses. Don't mark up your own testimonials to get stars.

Test your markup with Google's Rich Results Test after any change.

6. Trust and ethics rules

A law firm website is a communication about legal services, so ethics rules apply to it. Under the ABA Model Rules of Professional Conduct:

  • Rule 7.1 says a lawyer must not make a false or misleading communication about the lawyer or the lawyer's services. A statement can be misleading if it leaves out a fact needed to avoid a false impression.
  • Rule 7.2(c) says a lawyer must not state or imply certification as a specialist unless the certifying organization is approved or accredited as the rule describes, and its name is clearly identified.
  • Rule 7.2(d) says these communications must include the name and contact information of at least one lawyer or law firm.

During the analysis, flag case results without context, "expert" or "specialist" claims, guarantees and testimonials that suggest outcomes a reader could expect for their own case. States adopt their own versions of these rules, so have the responsible lawyer check the site against the rules in their state. This guide is not legal advice.

Trust also comes from the basics: real attorney bios with photos, bar admissions, a clear physical address and a privacy policy that matches the forms and tracking on the site.

7. Accessibility

According to W3C, WCAG 2.2 is the latest version of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines, and W3C encourages using the latest version. Level AA is the level most organizations aim for. You can catch many common issues in a few minutes:

  • Use the Tab key to move through the page. Every link, button and form field should be reachable and visibly focused.
  • Check that images have meaningful alt text and form fields have labels.
  • Look for low-contrast text, especially light gray on white.
  • Make sure videos have captions.

A quick check won't prove conformance. If you find several issues, a full review by someone who tests with screen readers is worth it.

8. Tracking and maintenance

You can't improve what you don't measure. Check that:

  • Form submissions and phone calls are tracked as conversions in your analytics account
  • Search Console is verified and shows no major indexing or security problems
  • Calls from ads, organic search and your Google Business Profile can be told apart
  • WordPress core, plugins and themes are updated, and backups run and restore

If maintenance is the weak spot, our WordPress website maintenance checklist covers the weekly, monthly and quarterly tasks that keep a site safe and its forms working.

How to run the analysis in one afternoon

Law firm website analysis steps: phone test, speed test, form and call test, page review, local SEO check, ethics and accessibility review
Six steps to run a law firm website analysis.
  1. Test on a phone. Walk through the homepage and two practice pages as a potential client.
  2. Run a speed test. Check Core Web Vitals in Search Console and PageSpeed Insights.
  3. Submit a form and call. Time the reply and confirm every lead reaches a person.
  4. Review practice pages. List missing or thin pages and pages without a call to action.
  5. Check local SEO. Compare your Google Business Profile, site details and structured data.
  6. Review ethics and accessibility. Flag risky claims for the responsible lawyer and run the keyboard test.

Write each finding down with the page URL and a screenshot. A list with evidence is far easier to hand to a developer or marketing agency.

What to fix first

Fix problems in the order they cost you clients:

Priority Fix Why
1 Broken forms, unanswered calls, slow replies Leads are already lost
2 Ethics issues Professional risk for the firm
3 Mobile and speed problems Visitors leave before they contact you
4 Missing or thin practice pages You can't rank or convert for those services
5 Local SEO and structured data Better visibility in local results
6 Accessibility and tracking gaps Better reach and clearer decisions

The short answer

A law firm website analysis checks speed, mobile use, contact and intake, practice area pages, local SEO, ethics rules, accessibility and tracking. Start with the intake test, because a broken form or an unanswered phone loses clients the site already paid to attract. Then fix ethics issues, mobile speed and missing practice pages. Most of the review needs only a phone, free Google tools and an honest afternoon.

Sources: web.dev, How the Core Web Vitals metrics thresholds were defined, ABA Model Rule 7.1, ABA Model Rule 7.2, W3C WCAG 2 Overview, Google Search Central, LocalBusiness structured data, schema.org LegalService.

Frequently asked questions

What is a law firm website analysis?

It's a structured review of a law firm's website that checks whether it turns visitors into consultations. It covers speed, mobile use, contact and intake, practice area content, local SEO, ethics rules, accessibility and tracking.

How often should a law firm analyze its website?

Do a full review once a year and after any redesign, migration or change of intake process. Test the forms and phone numbers every month, because a broken form costs leads without any warning.

What is a good page speed for a law firm website?

Google's Core Web Vitals call a page good when Largest Contentful Paint is 2.5 seconds or less, Interaction to Next Paint is 200 milliseconds or less and Cumulative Layout Shift is 0.1 or less, measured at the 75th percentile of visits.

Do ethics rules apply to a law firm website?

Yes. In the ABA Model Rules, a website is a communication about a lawyer's services, so it must not be false or misleading, and it must include the name and contact information of at least one lawyer or law firm. Each state adopts its own version, so check your state's rules.

Can I do a law firm website analysis myself?

Most of it, yes. A phone, Google PageSpeed Insights, Search Console and a test form submission cover the biggest problems. Bring in a developer for speed fixes, structured data and accessibility issues you can't fix in your site editor.

Get in touch

Have a question about my work or something I wrote? Send me an email.